Interview with Klaus Fichter
Megatrends such as nanotechnology and climate change are governing the direction of innovation policy. Do these megatrends generally lead to sustainable innovations?
Fichter: Climate change is increasing the pressure for innovations geared towards energy efficiency and renewable energies. Key technologies such as nanotechnology can be extremely useful in this regard, but only if they are used systematically. One example of this is the dye solar cell. This brand new, nano-based photovoltaic technology uses absolutely no energy-intensive raw silicon so it helps protect resources and lower costs while at the same time offering completely new application opportunities, as one of our latest research projects shows.
Concepts such as Design for Environment (DfE) encourage technical optimization of production processes or recycling-friendly product design. What other approaches and concepts result from the market’s demand for sustainability?
Fichter: On the one hand, the necessity to see products not in isolation, but as part of an integrated system. This also results in the need to systematically incorporate users of future products into the product development and testing processes at an early stage. This may seem simple and obvious, but where innovation is concerned, it happens all too rarely in practice.
In a research project, you investigated the innovation conditions and the influence of push and pull factors. According to this, there are different development pathways for innovations directed at sustainability?
Fichter: Yes, we were able to identify six fundamentally different development pathways. These range from a pathway that originates in a concrete sustainability problem, such as overfishing of the world's oceans, for example, to a pathway that we call "retrospective discovery". In this case, an innovation may achieve an environmental aim, like the T-Net-Box – a virtual answerphone on the net, but improved energy efficiency was not one of the original or explicit goals of the technical development and was only recognized as an environmental benefit retrospectively.
As part of its innovation management, Bosch runs innovation workshops in the thermotechnology sector, for example. What role can innovation coaches play in this in your opinion, and what contribution can environmental departments make?
Fichter: As the host of an innovation workshop and a neutral process consultant, an innovation coach can support the creativity of group processes highly successfully. He or she can also provide constructive help in resolving the conflicts that can often arise from the different points of view and interests of the various corporate bodies and departments and from cooperation with external partners.
Energy efficiency is increased not only by process and product innovations but also by larger system innovations such as the coated coldset process in the chemical paper chain. How can system innovations like this be organized over a whole value added chain?
Fichter: Klaus Fichter: Three factors are key to this: Firstly, a strong and highly visionary initiator who can win the support of decision-makers from important partner companies in the value added chain through skilled networking and so build up an informal promoter network. On this subject, I recommend a look at the book, "Never eat alone"! Secondly, you also need good networking to win over senior management, because without the support of the people at the top, all efforts at innovation will be in vain. Thirdly, support for the innovation network by an external innovation coach is usually extremely helpful.
The solar industry is one example of a sustainable growth market. Would you say that sustainability has now become a success factor in companies' business strategies?
Fichter: Of course, and that doesn't just apply to the renewable energies industry. In the IT industry too – a market that up till recently had next to no interest in energy issues – energy efficiency has suddenly become a hot topic. The energy costs of the data centers of Internet companies like eBay and Google are now a powerful cost pool. The energy efficiency of servers is therefore a key competitive factor. Take a look at current adverts by server manufacturers like IBM and Sun. This sector is undergoing a massive upheaval at the moment.
Interview with Dr. Klaus Fichter, in June 2007
Interview
Dr. Klaus Fichter,
Director Borderstep Institute for Innovation and Sustainability gGmbH, Berlin